A project on Medium to chronicle Indonesia’s anti-communist purges is now a moving digital scrapbook.

Hundreds of writers are volunteering their time to contribute to Ingat 65, a journalist-led project to ensure the 1960s massacres are never forgotten.

By Erin Cook
Splice Indonesia

It is difficult to find consensus on how many people were killed in Indonesia’s 1965-66 anti-communist purges. Some estimates put it at 500,000 deaths; others reach three million.

For decades, there was one official story about what had happened: nothing at all.

Only in recent years has it been possible for the official narrative to be freely challenged. And now a new generation of savvy young journalists is doing just that through the Ingat 65 — ‘Remember 65’ — project on Medium to chronicle Indonesia’s hidden history.

Chief editor Prodita Sabarini says that mainstream publications, particularly Tempo, Kompas and the Jakarta Post, have improved their coverage of the political implications of the period, as well as the demands of survivors and their families. But she believes personal narratives, such as those advanced by Ingat 65, are the most powerful tool to ensure the era is remembered.   

“I was one of those people who believed communism is bad,” as a result of the skewed education she received. “It was imprinted.”

A project is born

The idea for Ingat 65 was conceived after Sabarini saw the critically acclaimed 2012 documentary “The Act of Killing”, which was banned from cinemas in Indonesia, while completing a prestigious fellowship in the U.S. She was able to speak with the director, Joshua Oppenheimer, and their conversations began to change her perception of the past.

“For me personally, I started to acknowledge the sheer scale of the crime that happened as an adult. After a lot of deep talking and thinking, I returned to Indonesia wanting to do something about ‘65,” Sabarini says.

The film also opened up her eyes to how effective propaganda can be: as a teenager during the final Suharto years, she says, she was unaware that she was living under a dictatorship.

Launched in March 2016, Ingat 65 has been heavily influenced by a New York Times storywall project that saw writers from the transgender community share personal narratives. In that time, Ingat 65 has grown into a moving digital scrapbook featuring personal essays and stories from more than 100 volunteer writers.

“Sharing personal stories is valid, and it works, because there’s no assigning of blameit’s all self-expression and people trying to claim space,” she says. “Everybody should be able to express themselves.”

It’s an ethos that has paid off for Ingat 65, which has been able to steadily catalogue stories that otherwise would be in danger of disappearing forever along with the aging generation that lived through the massacre.  

A selection of propaganda leaflets blaming the Indonesian Communist Party for the 30 September 1965 movement. (Wikimedia Commons/Davidelit)
A selection of propaganda leaflets blaming the Indonesian Communist Party for the 30 September 1965 movement. (Wikimedia Commons/Davidelit)

Harassment and intimidation

But the project faces two major obstacles, according to Sabarini, an editor at The Conversation Indonesia who runs Ingat 65 in her free time.

Interest in fully addressing the crimes of 1965 waxes and wanes. Each year around September 30, the date on which alleged members of the Indonesian Communist Party (PKI) assassinated six army generals in a failed coup attempt, schoolchildren are made to watch a Suharto-era propaganda video that justifies the ensuing year of violence, while human rights activists call for resolution. Outside of that period, there is little sustained interest in the case.

And communism not only is still highly stigmatised in Indonesia, but illegal, and being accused of harboring sympathy toward PKI can lead to jail time. Indonesia does not share many of the tougher media restrictions imposed by some of its regional neighbors, but a culture of self-censorship persists amid intimidation by powerful political groups. At a cultural event held in Central Jakarta in 2017, hardline conservatives gathered to protest against young left-wing activists, accusing the group of being communists. While Sabarini had left the venue prior to the altercation, the Ingat 65 editorial team has also been targeted by anti-communists.

“We were cyber-harassedthey took photos from our Facebook [page] and said that we were affiliated with PKI,” Sabarini says.

The attack came just a few months after President Joko Widodo, himself regularly the target of communist slurs from opponents, said PKI should be rooted out.

 

An editorial cartoon from the front page of the Communist Party of Indonesia (PKI) newspaper
An editorial cartoon from the front page of the Communist Party of Indonesia (PKI) newspaper "Harian Rakyat" published 2 October 1965.

She is joined by a team of volunteers, largely made up of writers and academic, who have also faced online and physical harassment during periods of intense scrutiny.

“Being associated with communism is dangerous, even if you’re not communist,” says Sabarini. “Some of us were very, very scared, but we do this because we care. A lot of us have never been street activists—we’re just regular people who have jobs and want to do something.”

“We laid low for a bit and then refocused on the core of our movement, which is personal storytelling.” 

Erin Cook

Erin Cook is a Jakarta-based journalist covering Asean and Southeast Asian politics. She curates the Dari Mulut ke Mulut newsletter, bringing together the top stories and best in analysis from the region every Friday. Follow Erin Cook on Twitter.

Our newsletters are read around the world by some of the smartest people in media. Subscribe here.

From this week

Platforms

Facebook’s paralysis and negligence in tackling hate speech keep coming up in conversations.

Reuters — which has two of its journalists in prison in Myanmar for reporting on the country’s genocide — put out a special report on Facebook’s hate speech problem in the country. Facebook doesn’t have an employee in this country. Speech moderation is outsourced to Accenture in Kuala Lumpur in a secretive project called “Honey Badger”. But it’s not clear how many Burmese speakers are on the job. People working on the project sign a one-year renewable contract, and agree to never divulge that Facebook is the client. This is what Reuters found out about the project.
Reuters

Facebook’s head of news partnerships Campbell Brown made some off-the-record comments to Australian media executives about traffic referrals that stirred the hornet’s nest.

The Australian, breaking professional protocol in publishing details of that session, quoted her as allegedly saying, “We are not interested in talking to you about your traffic and referrals any more. That is the old world and there is no going back”. Of course, this isn’t new to many publishers who’ve seen their referrals dwindle in the past year. But it’s another reminder to everyone: Facebook is in the business of Facebook. If you’re in publishing and you’re still counting on Facebook’s referral traffic to keep your traffic numbers up, you’re delusional.
Nieman Lab

Transformations

Design

How do you redesign The Wall Street Journal’s 126 newsletters?

1. You cull them by a third. 2. You nudge your readers to subscribe with a prompt. 3. You update market info — in real time. 4. You let people hit reply. People like that whole responding thing. 5. Test readers’ resistance to your paywall. 6. You test a new email platform that plays to your strengths. 7. You add whimsy. At the end of it all, a newsletter is a conversation, and it takes more than machine learning to keep that going. All aboard for whimsy, I say.
Nieman Lab

The product design process can be notoriously difficult.

This is mostly because it’s often seen as an artistic moment of genius broken down into deliverables to a client waiting for results in a process with unstructured feedback. This is also known as herding cats. But we tend to forget that most effective product design works to fix a business problem in a collaborative manner that establishes goals, relies on prototyping, user feedback, and testing. How this product designer explores and tests his own journey is a lesson in process and how we work with it.
UX Design

Notables

Thanks for subscribing!