A startup is publishing India’s first braille lifestyle magazine. Here’s how they break even.

White Print has brought about a revolution in braille writing — and braille advertising.

By Mili Semlani
Splice India

The shrill clatter of pointed keys, piercing through white paper at a frantic speed? Certainly not my idea of music. On a visit last month to the offices of braille lifestyle magazine White Print, I was expecting a standard printing press.

But this one didn’t have any sheets of glossy images flying in the air, nor the peculiar smell of ink. The pandemonic machines, I was told, produced India’s first and, so far, only English-language lifestyle magazine for the visually impaired. Now, that was music to my ears.

The braille press at the National Association for the Blind in Mumbai. Credit: Upasana Makati
The braille press at the National Association for the Blind in Mumbai. Credit: Upasana Makati

Founded in May 2013 by a 20-something former PR executive, White Print is a 64-page monthly that aims to bolster the braille literacy movement. India has about 12 million visually impaired people but lacks an equivalent focus on braille literacy.

With White Print, Upasana Makati wanted to change that.

Diversity of content

It’s like any other lifestyle magazine but more diverse, says Upasana, who was included on the Forbes India 30 Under 30 list in 2016.

“We don’t stick to the theme of a typical lifestyle magazine, and also include stories on world politics, global affairs, sports, technology, culture, fashion, technology, inspiring human stories, short stories and even reader contributions,” she says.

Founder and owner of White Print Upasana Makati wants to revolutionize the world of braille literacy. Credit: Kanishk Seth

Readers say that while they may be visually impaired, they want to read about more than just topics relating to their specific situation “The community does just about everything and they are no different, so we want to cater to them in that particular way,” says Upasana.

For this purpose, White Print has a content-sharing partnership with Caravan, a longform magazine focusing on politics and culture, and also relies on paid freelance writers across India. “We are open to more editorial tie-ups to diversify the voice and foster inclusion. I am very conscious that our readers are exposed to well-informed global writers and their opinions too,” she said.

Readers can also contribute to the magazine, and contributions from people living or working with the visually impaired are encouraged. A Canadian scholar based in Hyderabad, Nikki Cochrane, has a popular column about raising her visually impaired child.

People and profits

White Print is a for-profit company. To that end, it has brought about a revolution not only in braille writing, but also in braille advertising.

While advertisers initially shied away from the idea of matte print ads without the traditional accompanying images, White Print offered them access to the world’s largest visually impaired population—many of whom also happen to be aware and empowered consumers.

“We have a lot of ads from corporates like Tata India, Vodafone, Aircel, Mahindra and Mahindra, Raymond, Pidilite group, and Coca Cola India,” Upasana says, adding that the magazine is breaking even. While most ads are text-heavy, there is scope for innovation. Coca-Cola India’s musical ad, which ran in the first issue, played a song each time a reader opened the center spread. It also bagged them an innovation award at the Goa Adfest.

“We are dealing with a big perception shift. Any organisation working with a specific group is tagged as an NGO,” Upasana says.

“But we are not one; we do not provide any tax exemptions or accept donations. So it is challenging for us to convince advertisers. But having a few big names on board has helped.”

A bootstrapped business

The magazine is sold for an annual subscription of 300 Indian rupees ($4.60) and readers can pay online or send money orders. While it only has a monthly circulation of about 300, with 150 of those copies going to individual subscribers, White Print is delivered to old age homes, libraries, schools and hospitals across the country, amplifying its reach.

Early issues of the magazine. Credit: Upasana Makati
Early issues of the magazine. Credit: Upasana Makati

As a bootstrapped startup, the magazine doesn’t have a marketing budget. A combination of social media efforts, external media outreach and partnerships has helped to spread the word about the product. White Print also works with NGOs, which stock the magazine in their libraries and share it with their networks.

Ummehaani Bagasarwala, an administrative assistant in Mumbai who has been a subscriber of the magazine since its inception, describes it as her “bestest buddy”.

“It empowers me to share news and updates with friends and family instead of them relaying it to me,” she says. “I eagerly await its arrival every month.”

Mili Semlani

Mili has spent four years exploring and reporting on the region as a writer and media consultant. She's worked on content strategy for Newscorp's fintech startup in India and edited Indonesia's DestinAsian luxury travel magazine. She also writes tech policy white papers.

From this week

Platforms

Columbia Journalism Review takes a hard look at the journalism funding done by Facebook and Google.

There are millions of dollars going into this space. While many are happy to take the money on the table, others question the ethics behind it. “The British Empire wanted trains in Kenya and India to run well, too. So their concerns are sincere, but the effect is more often than not a deeper immersion in and dependence on these platforms.” Of course this isn’t an issue unique to the tech giants — grant-giving NGOs have also faced similar critics.
Columbia Journalism Review

Governments & policy

Tools

Trends

New Naratif put together a solid story on how the Muslim Cyber Army works in Indonesia.

If you haven’t heard of the MCA (no, not that MCA in Malaysia!), they have been spreading fake news and driving hate speech along religious and ethnic lines. Worrying trend, especially in a country that’s been fighting fake news factories like Saracen. What makes this one different? “MCA looks more ideological, has thousands of networks in different parts of Indonesia and therefore the destructive power of this group is greater than that of Saracen.”
New Naratif

Transformations

The New York Times is partnering with FX and Hulu on a weekly documentary series called…The Weekly.

It centres around stories from the Times and the journalists that work them. This comes hot on the heels of The Daily, their incredible podcast about one daily story from the Times newsroom. This is part of the Times’ ongoing foray into entertainment: A New York Times Magazine feature is going to be a Netflix documentary series, and Brad Pitt bought the movie rights to the story of how the Times broke the Harvey Weinstein story. Also coming: a four-part series for Showtime about the Times newsroom during the first year of the Trump administration.
New York Times

Media startups

Talent

Design

SilverKris, Singapore Airlines’ in-flight magazine, nailed it with their recent redesign by Ink.

I usually have the same attitude to in-flight magazines as I do to, say, a swift slap across the face: I’d really just rather not, thanks. But this reworked version was good enough for me to forget my Economy Class kneelessness, even though the cover is easily the most forgettable part of the whole redesign: a crowded image with no focal point. But here’s why I love this redesign: 1. The layout and typography have integrity in that they are led by the content. 2. The section fronts have bold, opinionated design. 3. The reading experience is immaculate — even though they crowd little surprise nuggets in the gutter. 4. The illustrations by Stuart Patience are delicious. 5. The writing isn’t all travel-fluff and doesn’t suck. 6. Those are some mad infographics skillz. Here's an interview with the Ink creative director.
The Design Air

The Malay Mail did a website redesign.

Load times were a priority, and the new site scores well on that front. The digital team also prioritised monetizing content and enhancing their “programmatic setup”. For me, this is translating into lots of badly-placed ads for pointless leather accessories in duplicate and Outbrain-forward sewage. They are testing a new section with Mandarin content for Malaysians working in Singapore, which says good things about their user research. Structurally, the website is fine, although better hierarchy on the home and story pages would be a good idea. (Also, those Open Sans headlines need some kerning; they’re w a y t o o l o o s e.) I’m impressed with how their head of digital responded to a question about the cost of the revamp: he said the company saw it as an investment rather than an expense. Respect.
Marketing Interactive

The article page is arguably the most vital page for a news website.

Getting it right across platforms is the Holy Grail. Last week, The New York Times took a giant step towards getting it right. This involved streamlining internal efficiencies on their CMS as well as a better user experience across mobile and desktop on web and native apps. Advertising also got a major overhaul: they killed their cluttered right rail of smaller banner ads for larger, full-width, midstream ads for a much cleaner read—and it’s working: “Ads on the new page are achieving twice the click-through rate of our old design, and initial studies show higher brand recall and four-times the reader attention to ads.” Read about the process here.
New York Times

“Hi, so did you hear that crazy phone call that, umm, the Google Duplex robot assistant made to the hair salon?”

She had the whole uptalk (ending verbal statements with that millennialesque question mark subconsciously designed to maximise responsiveness) thing going on? as well as an “mmm-hmmm?” and even an “er”? It wasn’t just how real it was that blew my mind; it was that the person on the other end of the phone was able to have a complete conversation without suspecting anything. I think the tech is amazing; I think the the whole construct is creepy. Would Turing give the bot full marks? Hear it for yourself.
The Guardian

Google’s Duplex bot will now identify itself as a robot on the phone.

There were some serious concerns that Google was putting the ‘dupe’ in Duplex: “Silicon Valley is ethically lost, rudderless and has not learned a thing”. The company has clarified: “It’s important to us that users and businesses have a good experience with this service, and transparency is a key part of that.” What is it going to say, though: “Hey there, I’m Rishad’s bot assistant, so don’t be freaked out.”?
Twitter

Notables